Following earlier posts about the de-motivating effect of goals, I continue to reflect on why this is. In particular I have been considering goals about the generalist and specialist perspective.
I have written about the role of a generalist; I consider myself both a generalist and holistic thinker. As a generalist, I try to look laterally across the linear paths of work. This means I am not rigidly focused on issues seen ahead down a particular path. I am taking the blinkers off to see wider potentials in relation to delivery in work.
Developing a clear focus on goals is the subject of much academic research. example, MacGregor (2011) notes the reticular activating system concentrates on filtering out unsupportive information for a particular goal. This creates a narrow focus and potentially useful information in peripheral vision is shut out. In this way goal achievement reduces the potential gains from considering wider alternatives and perhaps testing validity of the goal.
Often consideration of broad and diverse information is discouraged and seen as a distraction. The generalist, to some extent, considers a tight focus a limiting rather than a supportive factor in their delivery. Therefore, rather than helping their motivation and achievement, they are a constraint.
Generalists which place an emphasis on their emotional and instinctual self are not rudderless; they are moving towards individual or shared goals, but goals are conceived differently. Following instincts to achieve delivery, rather than a tight focus on a goal, provides fulfillment (Alexander 2012). Those not following the traditional notion of goal seeking are not at the mercy of the elements, going where the wind takes them. Neither, are they unmotivated and unconcerned with achievement. On the contrary, while perspectives are different, they remain committed and motivated individuals.
Doubtless a strong focus on goals has a positive impact on delivery. Most generalists will agree that goals are valuable to provide a defined point of delivery. However, recognition of diverse views of goals by individuals with differing motivational responses and delivery is required. I agree with Ordóñez et al. (2009) who comment upon the nature of goals:
"Rather than dispensing goal setting as a benign, over-the-counter treatment for motivation, managers and scholars need to conceptualise goal setting as a prescription-strength medication that requires careful dosing, consideration of harmful side effects, and close supervision."
It should not be assumed everyone’s views of, and responses to goals are the same. Managers should be open to the differences, taking the time to investigate and understand them. Reflecting back to the employee this understanding promotes useful discussion and agreement of an approach to goal setting.
References

I started using reusable plugs and found them to be good. They are not as effective as specially made plugs bought from an audiologist. However, they are stop wind noise and don’t fall out when putting on your motorcycle helmet.