Generalist’s reflection on goals and goal setting

Following earlier posts about the de-motivating effect of goals, I continue to reflect on why this is. In particular I have been considering goals about the generalist and specialist perspective.

I have written about the role of a generalist; I consider myself both a generalist and holistic thinker. As a generalist, I try to look laterally across the linear paths of work. This means I am not rigidly focused on issues seen ahead down a particular path. I am taking the blinkers off to see wider potentials in relation to delivery in work.

goal_setting[1]

Developing a clear focus on goals is the subject of much academic research. example, MacGregor (2011) notes the reticular activating system concentrates on filtering out unsupportive information for a particular goal. This creates a narrow focus and potentially useful information in peripheral vision is shut out. In this way goal achievement reduces the potential gains from considering wider alternatives and perhaps testing validity of the goal.

Often consideration of broad and diverse information is discouraged and seen as a distraction. The generalist, to some extent, considers a tight focus a limiting rather than a supportive factor in their delivery. Therefore, rather than helping their motivation and achievement, they are a constraint.

Generalists which place an emphasis on their emotional and instinctual self are not rudderless; they are moving towards individual or shared goals, but goals are conceived differently. Following instincts to achieve delivery, rather than a tight focus on a goal, provides fulfillment (Alexander 2012). Those not following the traditional notion of goal seeking are not at the mercy of the elements, going where the wind takes them. Neither, are they unmotivated and unconcerned with achievement. On the contrary, while perspectives are different, they remain committed and motivated individuals.

Doubtless a strong focus on goals has a positive impact on delivery. Most generalists will agree that goals are valuable to provide a defined point of delivery. However, recognition of diverse views of goals by individuals with differing motivational responses and delivery is required. I agree with Ordóñez et al. (2009) who comment upon the nature of goals:

"Rather than dispensing goal setting as a benign, over-the-counter treatment for motivation, managers and scholars need to conceptualise goal setting as a prescription-strength medication that requires careful dosing, consideration of harmful side effects, and close supervision."

It should not be assumed everyone’s views of, and responses to goals are the same. Managers should be open to the differences, taking the time to investigate and understand them. Reflecting back to the employee this understanding promotes useful discussion and agreement of an approach to goal setting.

References

Alexander, S. (2012). "Why goal setting can ruin your life." Industrial and Commercial Training 44(1): 51-55.

MacGregor, S. (2011). Piece of Mind, Ebookit.com.

Ordóñez, L. D., et al. (2009). "Goals gone wild: The systematic side effects of overprescribing goal setting." The Academy of Management Perspectives 23(1): 6-16.

Difficulties with Goal Setting and Apraisels

The Dilbert perspective:

Dilbert.com

I have always found goal setting in work a particular problem. The thought of an appraisal left me with feelings of trepidation and vacuity. It makes sense consider the work I’ve done and how I might contribute in the future. However, framing as goals does not adequately represent my contribution.

While I deliver on specific projects, discussions with colleagues provide creative idea generation platform. This has more influence on delivery than the management activity on which I’m measured always leaves me flat. Project management aids delivery but fails to recognise contributing human relationships and cognitive application.

Perhaps my own concepts of activity important to delivery differs. I place great importance on developing ideas and concepts with colleagues. This encourages creativity in problems solving that increases the chances of success.

Appraisal systems are founded on quantitative measurement. However, creative input and human influence difficult to measure in quantitative terms. It isn’t easy to explain how I encourage a creative environment to appraisers who do not hold similar perspectives. Thus, a disjoint between myself as appraise and the appraiser exists. This results in a feeling that I cannot effectively express my contribution to work through goals. I have to bend and try to frame my work as goals which the appraiser seeks but know that I am not personally committed to them. However, I have to commit regarding results from my work activity.

Shock Factory (M Shock) stops the shock and brings back the fun.

I use a Honda Pan European on an 80 mile a day commute. I travel on fast A roads, through city centre and on motorway.

I had a Hagon rear shock on the bike which was fine for weekend use. On the regular commute I found things became very uncomfortable. I sent the shock back to Hagon for a rebuild. After a month of changing the preload and damping I could not get the bike setup to be comfortable while handling different road conditions on the commute.

I picked up a standard shock off Ebay. This was more comfortable, but like the Hagon shock, it seemed to be overwhelmed by the commute.

I contacted Mike at Shock Factory who makes the M Shock. After discussing my riding style, road conditions and weights, Mike built a shock. It came a couple of days after ordering with good instructions and details of the factory setup. On picking up the shock the quality of the unit is apparent. It looks and feels well built, a good deal better than the Hagon.

I refitted the Hagon shock for a week to compare with the standard shock before fitting the M Shock.

First time out on the M Shock, driving on the initial A road section of the commute the feel was similar to that of the standard and Hagon shock.  A particularly rough and potholed road dropping into the city was always really uncomfortable on the standard and Hagon shock. As I started down this road, what a difference on the M Shock. The shock seemed to soak up the bumps and the bike felt more controlled.

On the bumpy, fast A roads the bike feels much smoother and the feel from the back end promotes confidence, particularly in the wet. On the Standard and Hagon shocks the bumps couldn’t be differentiated between the front and rear suspension; it felt like the whole bike was shaking and bouncing over the bumps. With the M Shock the bumps were smoothed out and I began to get a feel for the front suspension as well as the rear.

The adjustable damping works well. It is easy to use on the bike with no screwdriver needed as with the Hagon or Standard shocks. The preload in no problem to adjust using the spanner included. I tried the bike two up and quickly managed to find the right setup. For solo riding on the commute, the factory setting were just about spot on. After 1000 miles, dialled up the damping and found an additional 4 clicks seemed just right. The pre-load was fine at the factory setting.

On the faster roads the bike feels more planted and in control and wallowing is gone. There is good feedback making twisty sections that bit more entertaining with a better feel of what the bike is doing.

In operation, the M Shock is way, way ahead of the Hagon and Standard shocks. Mike said I would feel the difference and he was not wrong. The shock has made my commute faster, much more comfortable and, riding to and from work, has brought the entertainment back even in the wet.

Generalists difficulties deciding on qualifications

The generalist seeks to maintain a wide base of knowledge and skills. Furthermore, they often work in several different organisational contexts using various methodologies. However, most managers tend to favour particular methodologies from specific disciplines. When recruiting, management look for experience, training and qualifications, which fit with their own view and their perception of the organisations view.

Generalists seek to gain knowledge and skills across disciplines and methodologies. They do not want to tie themselves down to particular perspectives. This makes decisions about training and qualifications problematic. For example, there are a range of qualifications associated with project management:

  • PRINCE2
  • APM
  • APMP
  • ITIL Service Management
  • P3O
  • MoV – Management of Value
  • Managing Successful Programs (MSP)
  • Agile Project Management

In an ideal world, generalist project managers would have all these qualifications. However, trying to obtain all these qualifications would take up much time and be costly.

Therefore, generalists decide on qualifications based on the sectors and organisations in which they may work. While pragmatic, this tends to specialise the generalists to particular organisations or sector by qualification defaults. They cannot make the best use of their generalist tendencies and abilities by required qualifications and organisations tendency to rely on particular methodologies.

Thus, generalists tend to seek qualifications, which are most widely adopted. At the same time they attempt to find qualifications with provide the greatest degree of genericism and scope. While enabling them to gain employment it is primarily on the basis for their specialist presentation rather than their generalist abilities and potential.

Cleaning those reusable ear plugs; sterilisation tablets

I use earplugs most days on my commute to work. I used throwaway foam plugs for many years but they were troublesome. They didn’t block the sound that well and had a habit of working loose and letting the noise in.

I started using reusable plugs and found them to be good. They are not as effective as specially made plugs bought from an audiologist. However, they are stop wind noise and don’t fall out when putting on your motorcycle helmet.

The next problem was cleaning them. Ear wax is a surprisingly sticky stuff and not easy to remove. I’ve tried many soaps, using hot and cold water and many combinations. Nothing work well.

Recently I had the idea of trying water with sterilisation tablets used for cleaning babyware. I popped a tablet into a litre of water then dropped in the earplugs and the case. After leaving them overnight, I removed them.

Hey presto, no earwax left on the plugs or the case. This approach also had the added benefit of killing off any nasty bugs that may cause ear infection. It’s taken ages but at last I am happy that my reusable ear are clean.

 

Problematic Aspects of Culture Change

There is a great deal of interest in changing and measuring corporate culture in support of organisational improvements. However, what culture is and how to measure changes remains problematic, as does the meaning of culture.

Often the phrase ‘the way we do things around here’ is taken to describe culture. Van Den Berg and Wilderom (2004) note this tendency to make such broad definitions, with culture expressed as simplistic shared perceptions of organisational work practices within organisational units that may differ between organisational units. Culture can be related to a wide range of behaviours, actions and ideals. It is complicated and the difficult to break down into constituent parts.

Another challenge facing those attempting to change culture is their ability to appreciate the current culture. Cultures are gestalts; they are wholes whose flavour can only be adequately understood and expressed by those who have inside experience of the culture (Hofstede et al., 1990). Organisational culture is a composite of many different aspects and is a context dependent construct. The meaning of culture depends on particular views and understandings of people in each organisation. The varied constructs and perspectives of culture are highlighted by Taras et al. (2009) who identify 121 instruments of quantifying culture. These instruments measure a range of domains, answering different questions being posed by management about culture.

A particular organisations approach to changing culture is dependent on beliefs about culture. The constructs of culture held by managers responsible for changing culture will determine the approaches adopted. As managers tend not to be true ‘insiders’ in relation to the cultures within an organisation, expectations and plans often derive purely from their beliefs of culture. Furthermore, it is difficult for individuals with dissimilar views of to influence managers in charge of culture change. Thus, improved understanding of culture change must involve co-construction by several insiders.

References

HOFSTEDE, G., NEUIJEN, B., OHAYV, D. D. & SANDERS, G. 1990. Measuring organizational cultures: A qualitative and quantitative study across twenty cases. Administrative Science Quarterly, 286-316.

TARAS, V., ROWNEY, J. & STEEL, P. 2009. Half a century of measuring culture: Review of approaches, challenges, and limitations based on the analysis of 121 instruments for quantifying culture. Journal of International Management, 15, 357-373.

VAN DEN BERG, P. T. & WILDEROM, C. P. M. 2004. Defining, measuring, and comparing organisational cultures. Applied Psychology, 53, 570-582.

Gantt Charts and Complexity: dissonance with its representation

By Mark Grimshaw

Since becoming involved with project management in the early 90’s, I have always struggled with some aspects of methodology. Training programmes present methodology which makes sense while being delivered. However, when faced with the vagaries of the real world they somehow seem to fall short. I’ve created and presented many Gantt charts and a means of visually representing a project but this also falls short. However, I have felt it has limitations but had not until not attempted to explore them

When managing a project the Gantt chart appears to lose some of its value. After a period of time, its importance to the management activity seemed to wane. It lacked the ability to represent the complexity of project activity. It did give a visual representation of progress, but the progress made didn’t really fit with that presented in the Gantt chart. It took on an unreal representation. Project board and sponsors liked the charts but as a project manager it was not representative of the ‘real’ project. Producing charts became more a chore than an asset to my project management. However, doubtless Gantt charts are valuable to others understanding of a project.

In my own limited way, I have sought to adapt my project management practices to deal better with the complexity, uncertainty and shifts which I find particularly interesting. The Gantt chart remains, with some unease, one of the most-used tools in my project management practice. I have not come across many project managers sharing my unease.

I recently came across some research by Geraldi and Lechter (2012) taking a critical look at the history of project management. A particular paragraph about Gantt charts was of special interest:

"While a Gantt Chart can be useful to cope with some of the ‘complicatedness’ of projects, and embraces the importance of time and timing, it is based on principles that are not valid to all projects. The consequence is a propagation of a management approach that does not explicitly cope with complexity, ambiguity, uncertainty and change. In that respect, the Gantt Chart fails to acknowledge insights from years of organization theory research and project management research with a firm grounding in contingency theory."

This paragraph highlights the complex rather than complicated nature of projects. This sheds light on issues I have been struggling with. I view projects through a lens of complexity and uncertainty, for others use a complicated lens is used. The Gantt chart is representative of a complicated project world but not a complex one. In a complicated world, it remains a vital tool but their use in a complex world is met with a necessary unease.

The problem does not lie with the Gantt chart rather changing meanings and perspectives of the project world it represents. It is unlikely that many project sponsors, and boards will hold a complex perspective of projects. Thus, dissonance project managers feel having a complex view will be with us for some time. It is up to us to manage the transition of meaning associated with the Gantt chart to add value in complicated and complex project worlds.

Perhaps this may assist a shift in thinking towards recognition of complexity, and the limitations presented by current project management methods. That is not to say tools and techniques are no longer useful. Rather it may encourage their being subject to greater evaluation in response to complexity.

References

GERALDI, J. & LECHTER, T., G 2012. Gantt Charts revisited: A critical analysis of its roots and implications to the management of projects today. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 5, 1-1.

Councillors and Performance Management

Councillors are an integral part of Local Government policy, strategy and decision-making processes. They play a vital and valuable role ensuring the council delivers value for money services to all its citizens. As such they form an integral part of Council service delivery processes. There is a great emphasis on improving services and reducing the cost of council services. At all levels, council employees are subjected to an ever increasing pressure to do more with less. Initiatives such as performance management aim to encourage individual performance and quickly address under performance.

Council employees are expected to have a high level of working capacity and competence. Significant resource has been expended on training and development of employees, ensuring they have the required knowledge and skills. Furthermore, they are supported in gaining a detailed understanding of the multiple business processes. They understand performance expectations and consequences for failure. Council employees are being pushed harder to deliver change.

Council services are delivered through a number of business processes supported buy information technology. Much effort is going into improving and cutting the cost of these processes. Councillors decision making activities are integral in council processes and influence their performance and efficiency.

Many council employees work within a performance management framework. These frameworks are there to ensure that people have the right knowledge and skills for the job while having clear performance objectives. If there is a problem with a particular process, managers can take action to remedy the situation, including addressing human resource related aspects.

Even with the centrality of Councillors activities to the performance of council processes they are not subject to similar performance management. Operational managers cannot take action to remedy problems with Councillors impacts on process performance. Thus, council management is not able to manage end-to-end process improvement. They cannot effect change where the processes go into the domain of Councillors.

With the thrust towards performance improvement, it is time to introduce some form of performance management for Councillors. We need to move beyond code of conducts to implementation of approaches for ensuring knowledge, skills and performance of Councillors. They need to be held accountable for their impact on operations performance of council services and processes. Councillors capability to add value to processes needs to be assured alongside their political inputs.

Not everyone is effective at multitasking, even project managers

 

Summary Points

  • Project management needs multitasking.
  • Research suggests that multitasking can significantly hinder a project manager’s performance.
  • To reduce negative impacts of multitasking, self-reflection is needed along with coping strategies.

Activities associated with planning, and organisation is foundational to project management. A project manager must manage many activities simultaneously and may also manage multiple projects. There is a view that to be effective, project managers must be good at multitasking. However, not everyone agrees that multitasking is an effective way of working.

Newell (2011) investigated multitasking and found it has a counter-productive effect on performance. Switching attention from one task to another is not without an overhead. The refocusing of mental attention is not instantaneous taking two or three minutes to achieve mental refocusing to a new task. This switching of focus seems a small overhead when compared to the perceived benefits of multitasking. However, over long periods, the compound effect of this small overhead may be significant and detrimental to the performance of a project manager.

Constant mental switching can be counterproductive due to the mental effort and stress created. Although switching focus may only take a short time, the repetitive impact is stressful. This stress is significant and should not be dismissed (Young, 2010). Each change in task takes energy, which is not limitless. People exposed to excessive multitasking can quickly deplete their energy and experience cognitive impairment (Hamilton and Weinberg, 2008). Project manager from a specialist rather than generalist backgrounds often finds multitasking a particular challenge.

Not everyone is good at multitasking. Project managers tend to be task focused and may not be sufficiently self-aware of their multitasking ability. Multitasking is important to project management and an inherent lack of multitasking ability does not preclude one from becoming a project manager. Strategies can be used to offset the downsides of multitasking but first an individual must have an honest appreciation of their own multitasking ability. This requires self-reflection and gaining this appreciation requires effort and openness, which bring further difficulties for many.

References

HAMILTON, J. & WEINBERG, Z. 2008. Multitasking teens may be muddling their brains. NPR Morning Edition.

NEWELL, E. 2011. The Myth of Multitasking. Government Executive, 43, 38.

YOUNG, M. S. 2010. Book Review: The multitasking myth: Handling complexity in real-world operations. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 24, 1046-1047.

Generalists are not always detail conscious

Generalists tend towards developing patterns of understanding. Their mode of thinking and understanding lends itself to supporting decision making between people. They often excel at questioning, facilitating and guiding individuals and groups. They act as a catalyst for identifying and considering alternatives, bringing to bear their breadth of knowledge.

The generalist will often achieve the maximum benefits through human interactions. Through interaction, they try to develop new understandings around particular issues or problems; they try to promote understanding within a wider context.

Often the detail of a particular situation or problem is not in the forefront of their thinking. The aim is to support those who can work up the detail of a particular solution rather than producing detailed solutions themselves. This is not to say that a generalist cannot work at a detailed level and many do. However, it is not natural for them. They would rather leave the detail to those with the relevant individual or collective expertise.